5 Drills That Are Better Than the Prowler

by Nick Tumminello – 8/02/2011
These days the Prowler is everyone’s choice for conditioning. Yet as much as I’m a Prowler fan, there are other effective conditioning options out there.
Note: in no way is the intent of this article to “bash” the Prowler. Instead, it’s to give you perspective on how to choose the best conditioning tool to fit your specific needs and goals.

Prowler Pros and Cons

In the fitness world it seems “you’re either with us or you’re against us.” In other words, something is either “good” or it’s “bad.” If it’s bad, we never use it. And if it’s good, we use the shit out of it.
The fact is that there’s really no good or bad exercises, just poor applications. In the case of the Prowler, I consider it to be a great tool that’s being way over-applied.
To use a tool effectively you have to understand its pros and cons and above all else, be objective. Here’s my list of pros and cons for the Prowler.

Pros

• It’s simple to use and most anyone can do it with little to no learning curve.
• It’s self-regulated. When you get tired, you stop and rest before starting again.
• There’s little danger of hurting yourself.
• It’s great for folks with knee, hip, or back injuries that prevent them from effectively performing lower body exercises like squats, deadlifts, and lunges.
• It’s just plain tough and a great way to push people to work hard in a controlled manner.
• The load is easily adjusted.
• It emulates many of the motions used in many sports like football, grappling/MMA, rugby, etc.

Cons

• It’s a slower movement than most sports, which are played at a fast, explosive speed while forcing the body to deal with momentum. As legendary strength coach Al Vermeil said, “Too much heavy weight sled or Prowler type work will make athletes great grinders. But it does little or nothing to make them more explosive.”
• It puts the body in an awkward, bent over position that, although similar to sports like football, is unlike any actual position seen in many other sports.
• It forces the arms not to remain stationary while holding onto the handles, which is nothing like running or sprinting where arm swing is critical. With the arms fixed in place, the shoulders can’t rotate as they would during normal walking or running, and anchoring the shoulders forces more rotation upon the hips and lumbar spine, which may not be safe over the long term.
• It forces athletes of all sizes (short, tall, etc.) to hold on in the same manner without accommodating their specific body needs and mechanics.
• It requires no eccentric action. While great for a deload day/week, in sports you must have great brakes (eccentric ability) to be able to stop the power your high-performance engine (the muscles) can produce.
• Many push the Prowler with a rounded lumbar spine for prolonged periods, especially as fatigue sets in. While more of a coaching flaw more than anything, the position needed to push the Prowler makes it difficult not to begin rounding the back as you fatigue. Furthermore, taller athletes may have to round their backs right away.
• It fails to create the full hip extension needed to express max power/speed in sports. That’s why most after Prowler pushing get fatigued in their quads and calves versus sprinting where they get glute fatigue and occasionally gluteal spasms, known in the track and field world as “butt lock.” This is why I always follow Prowler workouts with a few sets of a hip thrust variation.
• It can be costly to buy for folks on a budget.
• It takes up storage space, which in many small gyms or private training studios is often limited.

5 Conditioning Drills I Like Better Than The Prowler

At Performance U I use the Prowler mostly with general fitness clients and physique competitors as a “finisher” and with injured performance athletes who are unable to do the drills listed below.
But if you’re a healthy, uninjured performance athlete looking to enhance your sports performance by training in a manner that will have functional carryover to your sport, the following would be my go-to conditioning drills over the Prowler any day.

Hill Sprints

This is one of the absolute BEST ways to improve cardio conditioning, stride length, leg drive/power, and build a great looking, athletic physique. In addition, the impact on the joints is much lower than running on a flat surface since you’re always stepping up to something.
Hill sprints are also a more natural exercise, allowing the arms to swing while keeping the torso in a natural, upright position. It also forces you to move fast with the momentum of your legs swinging into the strides.
Find a fairly steep hill that’s at least 25 yards long. If you’re lucky, you’ll find one about 50 yards long. Run up the hill and walk down it as many times as you can in 8-15 minutes. Each consecutive workout, try to either perform more reps (trips up the hill) or simply lengthen the time. You can also wear a weighted vest (as long as it’s snug) and keep adding weight to the vest each workout.
With the vest, you can also undulate every other week.
Week 1 – use the weighted vest.
Week 2 – no vest and go for faster speeds.
Repeat

Note: I recommend walking back down the hill and NOT running down it.

Run Stairs

Find a stadium or local high-rise building and hit the steps. If you’ve never done this, it’s a very humbling experience. You’ll find that your legs get even more smoked from going back down the stairs to start your next climb than they do sprinting up them.
One side “benefit” from stairs running is having to think and use your balance and athleticism to not trip and fall on your face. You certainly don’t get that from the Prowler.
There are three primary ways I’ve used stairs as a conditioning tool.

• Skip every other step. (Take two steps at a time with every stride. Two strides covers four steps.)
• Same as above but also use your arms to pull yourself up on the side railings. This only works if you have a railing on both sides of stairs that aren’t too wide for you to hold onto.
• Touch every step and pick a specific leg to lead with every step. Then, change lead legs with each new flight of stairs. If it’s one long set of steps, change lead legs every 20-50 steps.

I like to progress the stairs workouts the same as I do the hill sprint workouts, discussed earlier. I’ll also include weighted vests here as well.

Shuttle Runs (aka – Suicide Sprints)

If your high school experience was anything like mine, the term “suicides” brings back gym class and wrestling practice flashbacks. I say keep the memory alive and add some old-school shuttle sprint work to your conditioning workouts.
Considering most readers aren’t concerned with improving their 40-yard dash times, I’m referring to 200-300 yard shuttle runs. That said, these shuttle runs would likely have a more positive effect on your 40 time than Prowler work since they’re more similar to the 40-yard dash.
I’ve already described how to perform 300 yard shuttle runs and an alternative using the treadmill in this article. Bring some of these shuttle runs into your life and you won’t just want to take a rest afterward; you’ll want to go home and take a nap!

Tire Drags

Dragging a tire by using a harness allows the arms to move in a natural action, increasing shoulder involvement while activating the core to work harder.
The harness also forces you to keep a straight, stiff spine throughout the exercise, regardless of how tired you get. Rounding the back at anytime will immediately look and feel very awkward, giving instant feedback to straighten out or stop and rest.
Also, unlike the Prowler, in which you can kind of Ôhang’ off the handles, you have to drive into the sled harness. If you try to just hang on it you won’t move much at all.
Here are my favorite ways to use the tire to build insane conditioning.

• With a heavy tire: Go 20-25 yards per set. Perform a total of 100-150 yards. Rest as needed between sets.
• With a medium weight tire: Go 40-50 yards per set. Perform a total of 200-300 yards. Rest as needed between sets.
• You can also undulate heavy to medium load tires each consecutive workout.

Here’s Oxygen magazine fitness model Alli Mckee doing some harness tire drags.

Tire Prowler Drags

This is Prowler pushes, version 2.0. I like using the tire for the following reasons.

• You control your torso position and can stand in a manner that best fits your size.
• You have two unstable handles to control, which forces the upper body and core muscles to work harder than with the stable handles of the Prowler.
• It’s more sports specific to grapplers and football players who have to control their opponent when blocking, pushing, or grappling.
• You can’t hang onto the handles. You must stay tight and strong, otherwise you don’t move.
• The tire Prowler push requires more balance and muscular control to keep the body from swaying side to side, which happens to most beginners when first trying this exercise. It also forces you to control the rotary forces by keeping the arms out and the rope the same length on each side throughout the exercise. None of this happens with the Prowler due to its stable and very wide base of support.

Use the same workout protocols as described with the tire drags.

Final Thoughts

Now, don’t get all bent out of shape simply because you’re emotionally attached to the Prowler. I’m NOT saying the Prowler is no good; on the contrary, I love it! But it’s just a tool, and a tool can be used or downright abused and overused.
You need to understand both the pros and cons of everything you do in the gym – even what’s immensely popular – and while the Prowler is a great tool, it’s also a slower, more grinding exercise that’s not as athletic or natural as the other drills I’ve provided.
The keys to training are variety, intensity, and specificity. I’ve given you some effective tools to incorporate these three keys into! Now get busy!
Wikio

Wikio